Brain Imaging: SPECT, fMRI, & QEEG and what they uncover in the brain

Brain imaging techniques play a key role in helping medical professionals and researchers understand how our brains work. Functional imaging allows us to see brain activity in real time by measuring changes like blood flow, electrical signals, or metabolic processes in the brain, which reflect how different areas are working during tasks or at rest. Three common techniques are Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI), Single Photon Emission Computed Tomography (SPECT), and Quantitative Electroencephalography (QEEG). These methods are used for different reasons, depending on the situation. In this article, we’ll compare fMRI, SPECT, and QEEG, focusing on their benefits and what they can tell us about different brain conditions.

Brain Imaging: Functional vs. Structural Mapping

There are two main types of brain imaging: 'structural' and 'functional'. Structural imaging is like taking a picture of what the brain’s physically looks like. It shows us how the brain is made up but not how it’s working, like X-rays or CT scans for example. These are useful for spotting problems with bone, muscle, or other tissues but don’t tell us much about brain activity. 

On the other hand, functional imaging shows how the brain or neurons are working by tracking changes in neuronal activity. Techniques like SPECT, fMRI, and QEEG give us a window into the brain’s function by measuring different signals related to brain activity.

Understanding Brain Imaging: Temporary and Spatial Resolution

When we talk about brain imaging, two important things to consider are 'temporal resolution' and 'spatial resolution'. Temporal resolution refers to how well a technique can track changes in brain activity over time. For example, how fast can it detect a change during an event like a seizure? This is important for seeing how the brain behaves in real-time.

Spatial resolution refers to how well a technique can pinpoint where the activity is happening in the brain. This can be difficult because it can hard to measure signals directly from specific areas of the brain without surgery. Some methods are better than others at locating which brain region is involved in a problem.

Here’s a simple breakdown of the three imaging techniques and their strengths:

• fMRI: This technique has medium spatial resolution, meaning it’s fairly good at showing where activity is happening, and high temporal resolution, meaning it can track changes in brain activity fairly quickly.
  
  
• SPECT: With medium spatial resolution but low temporal resolution, SPECT is not as good at showing quick changes in activity.
  
  
• QEEG: This method has low spatial resolution, so it’s not as good at pinpointing exactly where the activity is happening. However, it has the highest temporal resolution of these methods, meaning it’s excellent at showing rapid changes in brain activity. 

Functional MRI (fMRI) as a Brain Imaging Technique

Functional MRI (or 'fMRI') utilizes a powerful magnetic field along with radio waves to detect changes in blood flow related to neuronal activity. In an fMRI scan, increased blood flow indicates heightened brain activity in local regions. This means that fMRI doesn’t measure activity directly but instead guesses where activity is happening on a second-by-second basis by measuring the blood supply in that area. 

The output from an fMRI is precise and detailed, giving a 3D image of the brain which a clinician can manipulate and scroll through on a computer. The scan is usually performed while the patient performs tasks, so brain activity is matched up to when the task was performed to determine which brain regions were active in response to the task. A patient must stay very still during the task, because it must be performed inside the large donut-shaped part of an MRI machine.

fMRI is particularly useful in research settings for understanding cognitive processes and mapping brain functions related to tasks such as memory, attention, and language processing. However, the requirement that patients remain inside the MRI machine limits the kinds of tasks that can be performed. 

SPECT imaging as a Brain Imaging Technique

SPECT is a nuclear imaging technique that assesses blood flow in the brain using radioactive tracers injected into the bloodstream. It captures gamma rays emitted from the tracers to create images of brain activity over time. The method is similar to fMRI because it assesses brain function by looking at blood flow but is applied in different situations for a couple of reasons.

Firstly, a SPECT output usually appears blurrier than an fMRI output, because it averages recordings over 10-15 minutes. This doesn't necessarily mean it is less accurate but does mean SPECT doesn't have high enough temporal resolution to measure responses to tasks like fMRI. However, SPECT is typically better at identifying exactly which parts of the brain receive more or less blood flow over the time period and therefore are more or less active. Patients must stay very still inside the machine for at least 10 minutes, which limits applicability even more than an fMRI.

Looking at blood flow to investigate brain activity under SPECT is best for determining which brain regions are overactive or not working at all, over a long time period. It can also determine very specifically which regions are receiving reduced blood flow for physiological reasons. SPECT is therefore most suited to looking at long-term problems like stroke-induced damage, epilepsy, or neurodegenerative disorders. In these cases, SPECT is usually not very useful for identifying how the disorder affects a patient, but very good at identifying where in the brain the problem has occurred.

Quantitative EEG (QEEG) as a Brain Imaging Technique

Quantitative EEG measures electrical activity in the brain using electrodes placed in a pattern on the scalp. It continuously records neuronal activity with very high temporal resolution. The output from any EEG is very different from fMRI and SPECT – it looks like a series of lines on a sheet of paper. These are traces of electrical activity recorded from each electrode on the scalp. The “quantitative” part of the QEEG refers to a series of numbers and graphs which explain the EEG depending on what is being measured. 

The temporal resolution of a QEEG analysis is extremely high because it takes readings every few milliseconds, which can mean hundreds per second. However, the spatial resolution is comparatively now because each electrode records from a section of the scalp which could be a few centimeters across. Further, because the signals which an EEG reads tend to originate from deeper within the brain and therefore blend together before reaching the scalp, an EEG has to guess exactly where the signals come from. After the EEG signal is processed to a QEEG output, a complex algorithm estimates which section of the brain was responsible for each signal. Notably, a QEEG compares the data to a database of normal EEG signals, so the analysis process can figure out which brain regions are responsible for some signals simply by knowing what the signal looks like.

A QEEG output is organized according to the frequency of neuronal activity on a graph. Each range of frequencies is associated with different activities – for example, activity between 8-12 Hz might mean a person is trying to concentrate. Because of the way these readings are organized, QEEG is very good at investigating cognitive functions when they occur, but not very good at identifying where exactly they occur in the brain.

QEEG is particularly useful for assessing conditions such as epilepsy, Attention Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), sleep disorders, and other cognitive impairments. Clinicians can compare the output to normal values to get an accurate picture of how the brain is performing and identify the abnormal aspects of brain functioning. 

Comparing the benefits of fMRI, SPECT, and QEEG

Each imaging technique offers unique advantages and disadvantages depending on what is required. Here is a summary of some of the most important points:

Benefits of fMRI Brain Imaging

• Provides insight into which parts of the brain are involved in specific functions. 
• Best suited for studies where task-related activation of brain regions needs to be assessed. 
• Often used in research. 
• Requires a patient to stay as motionless as possible during the scan. 

Benefits of SPECT Brain Imaging

• Offers a broader overview of brain function over time. 
• Particularly effective for diagnosing conditions that involve changes in blood flow to specific brain regions. 
• Best for detecting long-standing damage which can be hard to see over short-term scans. 
• Requires a patient to stay as motionless as possible during the scan. 

Benefits of QEEG Brain Imaging

• Good for looking at the neural activity in the brain in real-time. 
• Often performed to look at brain function during a specific task or during a brain-related event of interest. 
• More flexible than fMRI and SPECT because there is no requirement to stay still. 
• Much more sensitive than fMRI or SPECT to small changes in neuronal activity related to brain functions, so can be used to look at more specific brain functions. 
• Less information about which part of the brain is responsible for electrical signals. 
• Highly effective for monitoring treatment responses in conditions like epilepsy or ADHD. 

How Brain Imaging is used in medical conditions

Brain Imaging for Stroke

Blood perfusion related to function is extremely important in stroke, so CT and MRI (which can include SPECT or fMRI) are most useful to assess the patient's condition. QEEG can then be used in addition to track post-stroke recovery in some cases. 

Brain Imaging for Epilepsy

In epilepsy management, QEEG is the gold standard for seizure detection due to its high temporal resolution, and can provide insight into which part of the brain the seizure originated from. SPECT and fMRI can also visualize perfusion issues and localize them to brain regions during seizures, which can help surgical planning if necessary. 

Brain Imaging for ADHD

It is possible to capture images of the brain which can support a diagnosis of ADHD or describe ADHD-related symptoms. No imaging modality can diagnose ADHD alone, but they can assist diagnosis in combination with other assessments. QEEG analysis is very sensitive to attention regulation and vigilance in ADHD and is sometimes used by practitioners during diagnostic or progress assessments. QEEG can be used initially to assess brain activity patterns for neurofeedback, which can be used to treat ADHD symptoms. 

There is now evidence that SPECT can help to identify and characterize ADHD in patients, but it is not used very often. fMRI is sometimes used in research on ADHD to find differences in brain activity between people who have ADHD and people who do not. QEEG is preferable to fMRI and SPECT in ADHD because it is faster, requires less preparation, and is more sensitive to relevant brain activity. 

Brain Imaging for Concussion and traumatic brain injury (TBI)

Brain injuries are very important to diagnose and investigate quickly, so imaging techniques are critical. SPECT, fMRI, and QEEG can all be used in TBI or concussions for different purposes. A SPECT scan can be useful for mild TBI over time, and fMRI could be used to link damaged brain regions to specific functions. A QEEG is often used to find which brain functions and brain rhythms are not working normally and determine how that damage impacts brain function.

Brain Imaging for Sleep Disorders

A standard in-clinic sleep study used to investigate sleep disorders includes constant QEEG reading throughout, which can measure depth, length, type, and effectiveness of sleep. Small EEGs are also used routinely to monitor patients when they are under anesthesia or unconscious. It is impossible or impractical to use fMRI or SPECT for a sleep study, but they can be effective in other ways, for example in sleep apnea and narcolepsy.

Summary of Brain Imaging Techniques

In summary, fMRI, SPECT, and QEEG each serve distinct roles within the realm of functional neuroimaging. Their unique strengths make them suitable for various clinical applications related to neurological and psychiatric disorders.

fMRI excels in research settings requiring detailed task-related activation analysis. SPECT provides valuable insights into longer-term cerebral blood flow dynamics across a range of conditions. QEEG offers real-time monitoring capabilities essential for assessing electrical activity related to cognitive functions or disorders. 

As these technologies continue to evolve, their integration into clinical practice will enhance diagnostic accuracy and improve patient outcomes. neurocare provides QEEG assessments for ADHD, sleep disorders, neurofeedback and more. We use evidence-based techniques to support therapeutic programs and produce best outcomes. 

neurocare provides comprehensive ADHD assessments for diagnosis and management using evidence-based techniques.

Click here to read more about ADHD treatment at neurocare >>

neurocare also provides assessments for sleep disorders which may include QEEG techniques.

Click here to read more about our sleep assessments and treatments >>